reddit body-recompmuscle-growthno-peptides

u/garcon-du-soleille: enclomiphene + protein + creatine + heavy training (a no-peptides muscle stack)

I'm open to evidence to the contrary. But from all the research I've done, I can't find a peptide that grows muscle. Steroids. Testosterone injections. Enclomiphene. Protein. Creatine. Lots and lots of time spent in the weight room. These are things that actually WILL grow muscles. (Edit: none of them will work without #6.) Obviously, I don't condone or recommend steroids for anyone. I looked into TRT and personally decided against it. That's just my personal choice. However, 3, 4, 5, and 6 are all things I use. But again… Please feel free to disagree with my statement in the title. But if you do, please also provide some evidence. Thanks! EDIT #2: As pointed out in the comments, Testosterone (TRT or Enclo) + HGH + Strength Training can indeed be a great way to build strength and muscle mass. I would just note that HgH alone won't do much for you.
Hot take

The author's title is half right — there are no peptides that build muscle, and the listed alternatives are exactly the stack that does. Enclomiphene + adequate protein + creatine + a real progressive-resistance program is the strongest non-AAS muscle stack you can construct, full stop. The post itself is the kind of pushback this corner of the internet needs more of: lead with what works, demand evidence, don't recommend what you don't use.

Overall
87
B+
Targeted goals
Body recompositionLongevityEnergy & metabolism
Goal Score Grade Weight Why
Longevity 85 B 15% Resistance training is among the highest-evidence longevity interventions. Protein adequacy and creatine both have longevity-relevant mechanisms, even though the author isn't framing it that way.
Cognition 80 B- 5% Creatine has well-replicated cognitive RCT evidence (especially in sleep deprivation). Resistance training has direct cognitive benefits.
Sleep & recovery Not targeted No ingredient with a sleep-targeted mechanism. Any sleep benefit is downstream of training fatigue, not a stack outcome.
Energy & metabolism 84 B 15% Resistance training, protein, and creatine all have direct metabolic mechanisms. Enclomiphene's effect on endogenous T also touches energy.
Body recomposition 89 B+ 65% A textbook natural-bodybuilder stack with one off-label SERM. Held off the A range by lack of dose specifics for protein and training program structure.

Ingredients (4)

Enclomiphene

prescription Moderate evidence

Enclomiphene on peptidelist.org ↗

Dose
unspecified
Mechanism
SERM (selective estrogen receptor modulator) that blocks hypothalamic estrogen receptors, increasing GnRH pulse frequency and amplitude, raising LH/FSH and endogenous testosterone production while preserving fertility.
Take
Author doesn't state a dose — typical off-label use for raising endogenous T runs 12.5–25mg/day. Enclo's appeal versus exogenous TRT is that it raises endogenous testosterone without HPG-axis suppression: same T benefit, preserved fertility and natural production. Effects on muscle mass are real but modest compared to TRT and depend heavily on baseline T. Body-recomp use is off-label; legitimate but worth saying out loud.

Dietary protein

lifestyle Strong evidence
Dose
unspecified target
Mechanism
Adequate dietary protein provides the amino acid substrate for muscle protein synthesis; leucine specifically triggers mTORC1 signaling. Protein needs scale with training stimulus.
Take
Author doesn't state an intake target. The evidence-based muscle-growth target is 0.7–1g/lb bodyweight (1.6–2.2g/kg) spread across 3–5 meals. Without quantifying intake, even the most evidence-based ingredient in the stack can be sub-therapeutic. The standard error in self-reported diets is large enough that 'eating enough protein' is rarely the same as actually eating enough.

Creatine

supplement Strong evidence
Dose
unspecified (typical 5g/day)
Mechanism
Increases phosphocreatine stores, supporting ATP regeneration in high-intensity work; modestly increases muscle protein synthesis; has well-replicated cognitive benefit, particularly in sleep-deprived states.
Take
Most well-evidenced supplement in human nutrition; the standard 5g/day works regardless of timing or loading. No dose given here, but creatine is among the most forgiving supplements — it works as long as it's taken consistently. The most likely failure mode is just not taking it daily.

Resistance training

lifestyle Strong evidence
Dose
"lots and lots of time spent in the weight room"
Mechanism
Mechanical tension and metabolic stress drive hypertrophic signaling via mTORC1 and satellite cell activation; progressive overload is the dose-response variable that matters more than any other for muscle growth.
Take
The author calls this out as required (#6 in their list), and they're right — none of the other items work without it. The phrasing 'lots of time' is vague; the actual dose-response for hypertrophy is roughly 10–20 hard sets per muscle per week with progressive overload, 3–6 days/week, sustained for years. Without that specific dose, the surrounding ingredients are sub-therapeutic.

Risks & interactions

  • Enclomiphene off-label use without bloodworkmedium

    Enclo for body recomp is off-label (on-label uses are male hypogonadism and fertility). Reasonable use requires baseline labs (total T, free T, E2, LH, FSH, SHBG) and follow-up at 6–8 weeks to confirm the SERM is producing the intended endocrine response. The post doesn't mention bloodwork; users replicating without it are flying blind on whether the drug is even working as intended.

  • Protein intake unquantifiedlow

    Self-reported 'I eat enough protein' is unreliable. A multi-day food log plus bodyweight tracking is the cheap diagnostic. Without it, the user may be sub-therapeutic on the single most evidence-based variable in the stack.

  • Creatine + insufficient hydrationlow

    Creatine increases intracellular water; users who don't drink adequate fluids may report cramps. Easy mitigation (drink water), low severity. Renal function should be normal — CKD patients should not freelance creatine.

  • Training program not specifiedlow

    'Lots of time in the weight room' is the right intent but not a program. A user replicating without periodization, progressive overload, or technique fundamentals will spend time without proportional results. The author's own outcomes presumably reflect a real program; the post just doesn't share what it is.

And one more thing…
ADD baseline + 8-week bloodwork (total T, free T, E2, LH, FSH, SHBG)

Enclomiphene for body recomp is off-label and dose-response varies enormously with baseline T. Without baseline and follow-up labs, you're flying blind on whether the SERM is producing the intended endocrine response — and on whether the modest body-comp benefit is worth the cost and side effects relative to just maxing out the protein + creatine + training that the rest of the stack already nails. Cheap diagnostic for an otherwise expensive intervention.

Estimated cost

/month
$30 – $200

Enclomiphene runs $40–100/mo via compounding pharmacy or telehealth platform; creatine $5–15/mo at 5g/day; protein highly variable depending on whether the user supplements with whey ($30–60/mo) or hits target via food alone (~$0 incremental). Gym membership not included.